Feature - Human Interest
The Games We (may no longer) Play: College Athletics in a Recession
RealView Sports by William Broussard, Ph.D.
Across the state (excepting the state’s flagship institution) the face of college athletics is
changing rapidly and drastically. Unfortunately, in the “Sportsman’s Paradise,” it’s
changing for the worst.
At the University of New Orleans, students voted down a referendum to establish a
student fee to underwrite the costs of operating their Division I athletic program. As a
result, their program is in limbo, as university-wide budget cuts will likely finish the job
Hurricane Katrina started and eliminate Privateer athletics indefinitely (and perhaps
permanently).
While Centenary (Shreveport) is not considering eliminating their Division I program,
their current conversations are tantamount to elimination in the eyes of the program’s
supporters. To reduce costs associated with travel and paying for athletic scholarships,
Centenary’s Board of Trustees has proposed that Centenary move down to non-
scholarship Division III, which has more regional competitive options than does Division I
(Centenary’s current conference membership requires them to travel to the Dakotas,
Indiana, Missouri, and Michigan). The move down from Division I to Division II is
considered a move towards a less prestigious division, and one that would negatively
impact recruitment for a university whose student body is composed of nearly 30%
student-athletes.
At Southeastern Louisiana (Hammond), they have eliminated the men’s tennis program,
impacting ten student-athletes on scholarship. Their tennis program won the Southland
Conference championship as recently as 2006.
Southland Conference competitors Nicholls State (Thibodaux) and McNeese State (Lake
Charles) will face substantial NCAA penalties due to poor performances in the APR
(Academic Progress Rate) reviews, and because of widespread budget cuts, their
departments will struggle more than ever to expand their academic services and support
for student-athletes. On the plus side, the reduction of scholarships associated with APR
penalties (Nicholls will lose scholarships in 6 sports, McNeese in 8 sports) will help their
budgets, but their coaches and administrators would much rather not have the problem.
At the University of Louisiana-Monroe, President Jim Cofer has been rumored to cut the
student fee allotment to athletics, and University of Louisiana-Lafayette President Joe
Savoie has cut their budget by hundreds of thousands of dollars, as well.
In a state whose institutions operate among the lowest budgets in Division I athletics in
the country, these budget cuts are not “trimming fat.” They aren’t even trimming meat.
We’re talking about trimming bone from bone, and perhaps even extracting marrow.
Truth be told, I am the first to admit that athletics is not the most crucial concern in
higher education. Frankly, the University of Louisiana System’s decision to raise the
funding of its member institutions in 2008 to 5%+ of the Southern average was a much
more important decision than any coach or athlete has ever made. And the work that
student-athletes perform in their classrooms and communities outweigh the importance
of the decisions they make on the field and on the court many times over. However, as
Hall of Fame basketball coach Dean Smith famously quipped, athletics is often considered
“the front porch of the Academy,” and if higher education in the state is to be judged by
the state of its collegiate athletic programs (save for the state’s flagship, largely immune
to budgetary problems) then Louisiana Higher Education’s front porch will need much
more than a good sweeping around before it resembles a gateway to a stately mansion.
Gov. Jindal’s posturing (and rumored preparation for a presidential run in 2012) about
refusing federal stimulus funding, and GOP house legislators’ decision to not even vote
on SB 335, which would have nearly halved the proposed $400 million cuts to higher
education in the state have placed the state’s institutions in a perilous predicament. We
aren’t talking about less than immaculate front porches as gateways to mansions, but
dilapidated front porches which lead to shotgun houses. Whereas in most parts of the
country, state legislators pride themselves in their funding of higher education, in
Louisiana, adequately funding higher education is considered wasteful spending.
I know better. And so do the people of Natchitoches and Northwestern State University.
Among my most treasured memories in my time as a student-athlete at Northwestern is
the fall of 1998, when the entire City of Natchitoches rallied around the success of the
university’s football team. The citizens and students packed the stadium on the
weekends, and it seemed that the entire city was awash with purple and white (and not
gold, for a change). Furthermore, the three extra Saturdays of home football games
were a boon to the local and regional economy (anyone needing evidence of this should
read a recently released regional economic report which states that Northwestern State’s
impact on the 10-parish area it serves is $352 million annually). The next year,
enrollment applications at the university increased substantially, as they did in 2006 when
Northwestern State beat Iowa in the NCAA Basketball Tournament. And given that
athletics offers Northwestern State and the City of Natchitoches so much to be proud of,
provides so much service to the local community (NSU student-athletes provide more
than 2,000 hours of community service hours every year), one thing is certain.
Budget cuts to Northwestern State University and to Demon Athletics hurt Natchitoches.
So while Demon Athletics makes no plans to cut scholarships to deserving student-
athletes, cut teams, switch divisions, or make any other drastic changes to its plans to
accommodate the impending budget cuts, it also means that Demon Athletics will struggle
to grow. And so will its plans to better and more comprehensively serve and represent
NSU, the City of Natchitoches, and north central Louisiana.
As an alumnus, former student-athlete, faculty member, and athletic administrator, I’m
proud to say that our one saving grace in the midst of this global economic recession is
that pride in Northwestern State University and Demon Athletics has not receded. And
though the decisions made in Baton Rouge may discourage, dishearten, and frustrate us
mightily they have not defeated us.
After all, by our own words, “Victory is on Our Side!”
RealView Sports by William Broussard, Ph.D.
Across the state (excepting the state’s flagship institution) the face of college athletics is
changing rapidly and drastically. Unfortunately, in the “Sportsman’s Paradise,” it’s
changing for the worst.
At the University of New Orleans, students voted down a referendum to establish a
student fee to underwrite the costs of operating their Division I athletic program. As a
result, their program is in limbo, as university-wide budget cuts will likely finish the job
Hurricane Katrina started and eliminate Privateer athletics indefinitely (and perhaps
permanently).
While Centenary (Shreveport) is not considering eliminating their Division I program,
their current conversations are tantamount to elimination in the eyes of the program’s
supporters. To reduce costs associated with travel and paying for athletic scholarships,
Centenary’s Board of Trustees has proposed that Centenary move down to non-
scholarship Division III, which has more regional competitive options than does Division I
(Centenary’s current conference membership requires them to travel to the Dakotas,
Indiana, Missouri, and Michigan). The move down from Division I to Division II is
considered a move towards a less prestigious division, and one that would negatively
impact recruitment for a university whose student body is composed of nearly 30%
student-athletes.
At Southeastern Louisiana (Hammond), they have eliminated the men’s tennis program,
impacting ten student-athletes on scholarship. Their tennis program won the Southland
Conference championship as recently as 2006.
Southland Conference competitors Nicholls State (Thibodaux) and McNeese State (Lake
Charles) will face substantial NCAA penalties due to poor performances in the APR
(Academic Progress Rate) reviews, and because of widespread budget cuts, their
departments will struggle more than ever to expand their academic services and support
for student-athletes. On the plus side, the reduction of scholarships associated with APR
penalties (Nicholls will lose scholarships in 6 sports, McNeese in 8 sports) will help their
budgets, but their coaches and administrators would much rather not have the problem.
At the University of Louisiana-Monroe, President Jim Cofer has been rumored to cut the
student fee allotment to athletics, and University of Louisiana-Lafayette President Joe
Savoie has cut their budget by hundreds of thousands of dollars, as well.
In a state whose institutions operate among the lowest budgets in Division I athletics in
the country, these budget cuts are not “trimming fat.” They aren’t even trimming meat.
We’re talking about trimming bone from bone, and perhaps even extracting marrow.
Truth be told, I am the first to admit that athletics is not the most crucial concern in
higher education. Frankly, the University of Louisiana System’s decision to raise the
funding of its member institutions in 2008 to 5%+ of the Southern average was a much
more important decision than any coach or athlete has ever made. And the work that
student-athletes perform in their classrooms and communities outweigh the importance
of the decisions they make on the field and on the court many times over. However, as
Hall of Fame basketball coach Dean Smith famously quipped, athletics is often considered
“the front porch of the Academy,” and if higher education in the state is to be judged by
the state of its collegiate athletic programs (save for the state’s flagship, largely immune
to budgetary problems) then Louisiana Higher Education’s front porch will need much
more than a good sweeping around before it resembles a gateway to a stately mansion.
Gov. Jindal’s posturing (and rumored preparation for a presidential run in 2012) about
refusing federal stimulus funding, and GOP house legislators’ decision to not even vote
on SB 335, which would have nearly halved the proposed $400 million cuts to higher
education in the state have placed the state’s institutions in a perilous predicament. We
aren’t talking about less than immaculate front porches as gateways to mansions, but
dilapidated front porches which lead to shotgun houses. Whereas in most parts of the
country, state legislators pride themselves in their funding of higher education, in
Louisiana, adequately funding higher education is considered wasteful spending.
I know better. And so do the people of Natchitoches and Northwestern State University.
Among my most treasured memories in my time as a student-athlete at Northwestern is
the fall of 1998, when the entire City of Natchitoches rallied around the success of the
university’s football team. The citizens and students packed the stadium on the
weekends, and it seemed that the entire city was awash with purple and white (and not
gold, for a change). Furthermore, the three extra Saturdays of home football games
were a boon to the local and regional economy (anyone needing evidence of this should
read a recently released regional economic report which states that Northwestern State’s
impact on the 10-parish area it serves is $352 million annually). The next year,
enrollment applications at the university increased substantially, as they did in 2006 when
Northwestern State beat Iowa in the NCAA Basketball Tournament. And given that
athletics offers Northwestern State and the City of Natchitoches so much to be proud of,
provides so much service to the local community (NSU student-athletes provide more
than 2,000 hours of community service hours every year), one thing is certain.
Budget cuts to Northwestern State University and to Demon Athletics hurt Natchitoches.
So while Demon Athletics makes no plans to cut scholarships to deserving student-
athletes, cut teams, switch divisions, or make any other drastic changes to its plans to
accommodate the impending budget cuts, it also means that Demon Athletics will struggle
to grow. And so will its plans to better and more comprehensively serve and represent
NSU, the City of Natchitoches, and north central Louisiana.
As an alumnus, former student-athlete, faculty member, and athletic administrator, I’m
proud to say that our one saving grace in the midst of this global economic recession is
that pride in Northwestern State University and Demon Athletics has not receded. And
though the decisions made in Baton Rouge may discourage, dishearten, and frustrate us
mightily they have not defeated us.
After all, by our own words, “Victory is on Our Side!”